Charming Chinese Challenge by Troy Hooser

Effect

The Charming Chinese Challenge is a visually stunning coin magic routine where three Chinese coins are threaded onto a ribbon. One by one, the coins magically melt off the ribbon without any visible manipulation, defying logic. The routine often includes a dramatic finale where the coins reappear on the ribbon before vanishing completely.

Full details

The trick involves three Chinese coins (charms) and a ribbon. The coins are threaded onto the ribbon, and through a series of deceptive moves, they appear to pass through the ribbon and vanish. Some versions include a "kickback" moment where the coins reappear on the ribbon before disappearing again. The routine is highly interactive, often involving spectators to verify the impossibility of the effect.

The Artisan Chinese Coin Set by TCC is frequently recommended for this trick due to its high-quality coins and matching ribbon. The coins are soft and well-made, ensuring smooth handling. Some performers also use a gimmick (referred to as a "turtle") to enhance the routine, though this is optional.

Who should consider the trick

This trick is ideal for:

• Intermediate to advanced coin workers familiar with sleights like the third-finger curl palm.
• Performers who enjoy visual, interactive magic with a strong puzzle-like presentation.
• Those looking for a compact, portable routine that can be performed walk-around or at a table.

Information on how difficult it is to perform

The Charming Chinese Challenge requires precision and practice, especially for the sleight-heavy versions. Key techniques include:

• Coin palming (third-finger curl palm).
• Ribbon manipulation to create the illusion of coins passing through.
• Timing and misdirection to sell the magical moments.

While the basic routine can be learned with moderate effort, advanced variations (like Avi Yap’s Threaded) demand higher skill levels. Beginners may want to start with Troy Hooser’s original version before attempting more complex adaptations.

What magicians say

• Craig Petty (Magic TV) praises the Artisan Chinese Coin Set as the best for this routine, calling it "absolutely the best coins I've ever found." He highlights the visual impact and commercial appeal of the trick.
• Roo (Roo’s Reviews) admits he was skeptical of the Charming Chinese Challenge plot but found Threaded by Avi Yap compelling due to its kickback finale and high-quality props. He notes that while it hasn’t fully converted him, it’s the first version that made him want to perform the effect.
• Penguin Magic lists the Charming Chinese Challenge among the top-tier coin magic effects, emphasizing its strong audience reactions and deceptive mechanics.

Overall, the Charming Chinese Challenge is a classic yet polarizing routine—some magicians love its visual and interactive nature, while others find it leans too much into puzzle territory. However, modern adaptations like Threaded have reinvigorated interest by adding new twists and improved props.