Cylinder And Coins by Joshua Jay and Tim Conover

Effect

The Cylinder and Coins trick involves a small leather or metal tube (the cylinder) and several coins. The magician places coins inside the cylinder, but they vanish one by one in a visually clean manner. The final coin may reappear in an impossible location, or the cylinder itself may prove empty despite the coins being seen inside moments earlier. The effect is a modern take on classic coin vanishes, with a focus on smooth handling and clear visual moments.

Full Details

The trick is a refined version of traditional coin magic, often using a leather or metal cylinder as the central prop. Some versions, like Tim Conover’s, emphasize forensic cleanliness—meaning every action appears natural, leaving no room for suspicion. The routine typically includes multiple vanishes, with coins disappearing one after another. The final load (where the last coin vanishes or reappears) is a key moment, though some reviewers note practicality concerns with this step.

Who Should Consider the Trick

This trick suits magicians who enjoy coin magic but want a structured routine with a prop. It works well for close-up performances, whether for live audiences or video. Those who prefer visual magic over complex sleight-of-hand will appreciate the clear, step-by-step vanishes. However, it may not be ideal for beginners, as some versions require precise timing and handling.

Difficulty

The difficulty varies by version. Some, like Joshua Jay’s, are designed to be accessible with practice, while others, like Tim Conover’s, demand higher skill levels for flawless execution. The core moves are not overly complex, but the routine relies on smooth transitions and natural misdirection. Reviewers suggest practicing the final load carefully, as it can be the trickiest part.

What Magicians Say

• AlakazamMagicUK describes it as part of a versatile magic survival kit, praising its visual impact and practicality for live and video performances.
• Magic-TV notes its modern take on a classic but mentions practicality concerns with the final load, scoring it highly for creativity.
• Noel Qualter (via AlakazamMagicUK) calls Tim Conover’s version a "masterclass in coin magic," highlighting its forensic cleanliness and storytelling potential.

The trick earns praise for its visual clarity and modern feel, though some versions may require extra practice to perfect.