Do as I Do

Effect

The "Do as I Do" trick is a classic card routine where the magician and a spectator each select a card under seemingly identical conditions. Despite the fairness of the process, the two chosen cards mysteriously match or interact in an impossible way. The effect creates a strong sense of coincidence and impossibility, often leaving audiences stunned by the apparent synchronicity between the magician and spectator.

Full Details

The trick typically involves a standard deck of cards, though some versions use gimmicked or specially prepared cards for added impact. The magician and spectator each shuffle or cut their own portion of the deck, select a card, and place it back in the other’s half. When revealed, the selections match perfectly, or the cards appear in impossible locations. Some variations include additional phases, such as revealing a royal flush or blank cards, enhancing the surprise.

The method varies—some versions rely on clever card reversals, while others use subtle forces or gimmicks. The best versions emphasize fairness, making the spectator feel they had a free choice.

Who Should Consider the Trick

• Beginners: Some versions require no sleight of hand, making them accessible to newcomers.
• Intermediate performers: More advanced routines offer deeper deception and stronger impact.
• Mentalism enthusiasts: The trick can be framed as a psychological experiment or synchronicity demonstration.
• Close-up and parlor magicians: The effect plays well in both intimate and slightly larger settings.

Information on How Difficult It Is to Perform

Difficulty varies by version:

• Beginner-friendly: Some methods rely on simple reversals or prearranged cards, requiring minimal skill.
• Intermediate: Versions with multiple phases or subtle handling may need practice for smooth execution.
• Advanced: Routines with examinable cards or additional gimmicks may require precise timing and audience management.

Most versions emphasize presentation over technical difficulty, making them suitable for performers who prioritize storytelling and engagement.

What Magicians Say

• Scott McKay (AlakazamMagicUK) calls it a "go-to trick" and praises its emotional impact, highlighting its power as simple, classic magic.
• Ryan Kirby (Magic-TV) demonstrates how the self-working nature of the trick makes it strong for performers who value simplicity.
• Steve (RealMagicReview) singles out a version where two spectators unknowingly match each other’s choices, calling it a "jaw-dropping moment."
• BestMagic recommends a beginner-friendly version for its reliability, noting it requires no sleight of hand.
• Cameron Francis (BigBlindMedia) expands the concept with a multi-phase routine, calling it a "mini-masterclass" in the "Do as I Do" style.

Magicians consistently praise the trick for its strong audience reactions and versatility, making it a worthwhile addition to any performer’s repertoire.