Free Will by Craig Petty
Created by: Craig Petty
Key features
Spectator-driven routine with free choice of coin order
Uses copper, silver, and brass coins for clear visual contrast
Nightshade gimmicks simplify execution, making it almost self-working
Requires the Nightshade Coin Set to perform
Ideal for close-up magic with high audience interaction
Pros
Highly engaging due to spectator involvement
Clear visual contrast with the three coin types
Nearly self-working with the Nightshade gimmicks
Smooth performance with minimal sleight of hand required
Cons
Requires the Nightshade Coin Set, limiting accessibility
May not be suitable for performers who prefer non-gimmicked tricks
Effect
Free Will is a three-coin across routine where the spectator decides the order in which the coins move from one hand to the other. The magician presents three distinct coins—typically copper, silver, and brass—for clear visual contrast. The spectator freely chooses which coin moves first, second, and third, making the routine highly interactive. Despite the spectator's choices, the coins impossibly travel from one hand to the other without any visible sleight of hand. The effect is clean, visual, and leaves the audience baffled.
Full Details
The trick uses three coins of different metals (copper, silver, and brass) to ensure clarity and contrast. The routine is designed to be nearly self-working thanks to the Nightshade Coin Set gimmicks, which simplify the mechanics. The magician never brings their hands together, maintaining the illusion of impossibility. The spectator's choices are entirely free, with no force or equivocation, making the effect feel organic and fair.
The coins are placed in one hand, which remains closed until all three have "jumped" to the other hand in the order chosen by the spectator. The magician emphasizes the impossibility of the coins moving without any visible action, reinforcing the magical moment.
Who Should Consider the Trick
- Coin Magicians: Those who enjoy coin magic and want a strong, interactive routine.
- Performers Who Value Spectator Involvement: The trick thrives on audience participation, making it great for engaging spectators.
- Beginners to Intermediate Magicians: The gimmicks reduce the need for advanced sleight of hand, making it accessible.
- Workers Looking for a Quick Reset: The routine resets quickly, making it practical for table hopping or walkaround performances.
Information on How Difficult It Is to Perform
The difficulty level is low to moderate, depending on the performer's comfort with coin magic. The Nightshade gimmicks handle much of the heavy lifting, minimizing the need for complex sleights. However, smooth presentation and timing are crucial to selling the illusion.
- Handling: Minimal sleight of hand is required, but natural movements and misdirection are key.
- Practice Needed: While the mechanics are simple, rehearsing the pacing and spectator interaction will enhance the effect.
- Angle Sensitivity: The trick is angle-friendly, but performers should be mindful of their hand positioning to maintain the illusion.
What Magicians Say
- Craig Petty (Magic-TV): "The Nightshade gimmicks make it almost close to self-working at this point, which is amazing. The spectator involvement and clear visual effect make it a standout routine."
- Alex Kirk (Monster Magic Shop): "Free Will is a strong trick, though I find the routine a bit dull compared to other releases. The gimmick is well-made, but the presentation needs more excitement."
- Mark Stevens (Stevens Magic Emporium): "The principle of equivocation in Free Will is ingenious. It’s a killer effect that always hits well with audiences."
- Saturn Magic Shop: "A clean, examinable routine that’s ideal for workers. The spectator’s free choice adds a strong psychological element."
Overall, Free Will is praised for its spectator-driven nature, ease of execution, and strong visual impact, making it a worthwhile addition to a magician’s repertoire.
What people are saying about Free Will
magic-tv says...
The Nightshade gimmicks make it so much easier—it's almost close to self-working at this point, which is amazing. [...] The routine is engaging and visually clear, with playful commentary adding charm.
monstermagicshop says...
Free Will is a self-working signed-card-to-impossible-location effect. While technically strong, it lacks excitement compared to other releases. The gimmick is well-made but requires DIY assembly.
MurphysMagicSupplies says...
Free Will is the ultimate version of a plot I've been obsessed with for over a decade. The gaffs in the Nightshade set make it almost not completely self-working, but it's not difficult to do at all.
SaturnMagicShop says...
Free Will by Sean Manoj is a signed card revelation where the spectator stops the dealer at any point to find their card. It's considered his strongest release yet, with a simple gimmick and easy handling.
StevensMagicEmporium says...
Free Will is one of the greatest effects, with an ingenious psychological subtext. It's a killer routine that always hits well and is a favorite among mentalism performers.
Performance videos
Free Will from The Nightshade Coin Set | Entirely Your Choice
magic-tv mentioned this magic trick in this video.
Review videos
ESP Pouch - Vince Wilson
StevensMagicEmporium mentioned this magic trick in this video.
The Nightshade Coin Set | 5x5 With Craig Petty
magic-tv mentioned this magic trick in this video.
Promotional videos
WonderFob by Jon Allen
MurphysMagicSupplies mentioned this magic trick in this video.
Other videos
The Saturday Show April 5th 2025 - www.MonsterMagic.co.uk
monstermagicshop mentioned this magic trick in this video.
Saturn Magic Live Stream Sunday march 30th 2025
SaturnMagicShop mentioned this magic trick in this video.
Aaron Fisher and Angelo Carbone are BACK! | March 26
MurphysMagicSupplies mentioned this magic trick in this video.