Holy by Paul Gordon

Created by: Paul Gordon

Holy by Paul Gordon is a captivating close-up card trick where a signed card (typically the King or Jack of Spades) repeatedly appears in impossible locations, defying logic. The spectator follows the card as it flips face-up, face-down, and changes positions, culminating in a mind-blowing triple revelation: it's the only card facing the opposite direction, the only one with a blue back, and the only one with a large hole punched through it. This visual and interactive trick is perfect for close-up performances, leaving audiences utterly baffled. Buyers should note that while the method is clever and the props are examinable, the trick requires intermediate card-handling skills and a thoughtful presentation to maximize its impact.

Key features

Examinable props with no gimmicks hidden on the performer
Triple-whammy climax (direction, color, and hole) for maximum impact
Intermediate-level card handling required
Versatile presentation options (e.g., gambling, supernatural themes)

Pros

Strong visual and interactive elements
Completely examinable at the end
Flexible presentation styles
Highly memorable for spectators

Cons

Performance style may not suit everyone
Requires practice to master the pacing
Not ideal for large-stage settings

Effect

The trick Holy by Paul Gordon involves a signed card that repeatedly appears in impossible locations. The magician shows a card, often the King or Jack of Spades, which changes position, turns face up or down, and undergoes other transformations. The climax reveals the card is the only one facing the opposite way, the only one with a different-colored back, and the only one with a hole punched through it. This combination of impossible changes creates a strong reaction from spectators.

Full Details

Holy is a packet trick that uses a small set of cards. The effect builds gradually, with the card seemingly moving unpredictably before the final revelation. The trick is fully examinable, meaning spectators can inspect the cards at the end. The method relies on clever construction rather than sleight of hand, making it accessible to many performers.

The presentation can vary—some magicians use a gambling theme ("keep your eye on the card"), while others incorporate storytelling, such as the idea of selling one's soul to the devil (explaining the hole in the card). The trick is structured to allow multiple phases, keeping the audience engaged before the final surprise.

Who Should Consider the Trick

This trick suits magicians who enjoy:

Packet tricks (small, self-contained routines with a few cards).
Interactive magic where spectators follow a card’s journey.
Presentational flexibility—the effect can be adapted to different themes.

It may not be ideal for those who prefer impromptu magic or dislike memorized sequences.

Difficulty

Holy is considered intermediate in difficulty. While it doesn’t require advanced sleight of hand, it does involve:

Memorizing a sequence of moves.
Maintaining smooth pacing to avoid confusion.
Presenting clearly so spectators follow the transformations.

Steve Faulkner notes that while the trick has "lots to remember," it becomes intuitive with practice.

What Magicians Say

Steve Faulkner praises the trick’s examinability and strong finish, calling it a "triple whammy" effect. He mentions that while some find Paul Gordon’s performance style divisive, the trick itself is well-constructed.
Tom appreciates the speed and "ordered chaos" of the routine but acknowledges the need for rehearsal.
Dale Moore suggests alternative presentations, such as linking the hole in the card to a story about losing one’s soul.
Maxim X says they wouldn’t perform it at paid gigs but would keep it in their everyday carry for casual performances.

Overall, Holy is a well-regarded trick with a strong visual payoff, making it a solid choice for magicians who enjoy structured, multi-phase routines.

What people are saying about Holy

RealMagicReview (Steve Faulkner) says...

This is one of those tricks where the key is not to rush—enjoy the chaos just before they realize what’s happening. The triple whammy at the end completely fries people.