Oil and Water by Simon Lovell, Long Long, Bacon Magic, Josh Burch, Anthony Vasquez, Dani DaOrtiz, and Air1

Effect

The Oil and Water trick is a classic card effect where red and black cards appear to mix together randomly, then magically separate into two distinct groups. The magician typically starts with a small packet of cards (often four red and four black) and shows them alternating in color. After a magical gesture—such as a snap, blow, or shake—the cards instantly rearrange themselves into two separate piles, one entirely red and the other entirely black. Some versions expand this effect to an entire deck, making the separation even more visually striking.

Full Details

Oil and Water is a versatile trick with many variations, ranging from self-working methods to sleight-heavy routines. Some versions use gimmicked cards for instant visual separation, while others rely on clever shuffles, displacements, or false deals to achieve the effect. The trick can be performed with standard playing cards or specialized decks, such as those with contrasting colors or themed designs (e.g., heroes vs. villains).

Key features of the trick include:

• Visual separation: The moment when the cards "unmix" is often instantaneous and surprising.
• Audience participation: Some routines allow spectators to mix the cards themselves, enhancing the illusion of fairness.
• Multiple phases: Advanced versions may include additional phases, such as re-mixing and re-separating the cards for added impact.

Who Should Consider the Trick

Oil and Water is suitable for:

• Beginners: Many versions are self-working or require minimal sleight of hand.
• Intermediate performers: Those looking to refine their handling and presentation.
• Advanced magicians: Some variations incorporate complex moves like Greek deals, second deals, or displacement techniques.
• Close-up and walkaround performers: The trick is compact and works well in casual settings.

Difficulty

The difficulty of Oil and Water varies widely depending on the method:

• Easy: Self-working versions with minimal sleight of hand (e.g., Saturn Magic’s "L Oil and Water").
• Moderate: Routines involving false shuffles or simple displacements (e.g., Reid Ferry’s spectator-handling methods).
• Advanced: Techniques like Greek deals, second deals, or intricate packet switches (e.g., some professional-only variations).

What Magicians Say

• Craig Petty (Magic-TV) praises the trick for being "quick to perform and visually appealing," though he notes some versions may be too brief for certain audiences.
• Reid Ferry calls it "strong magic" when performed cleanly, emphasizing spectator involvement to enhance fairness.
• Saturn Magic describes their version as "foolproof and visually stunning," with a powerful kicker ending.
• Josh Burch (Peanut Butter & Cheese) offers a playful, food-themed take on the classic plot, making it more engaging for casual performances.
• Tom Dobrowolski highlights the importance of structure in routines like Oil and Water, ensuring the effect builds to a memorable conclusion.

Overall, Oil and Water remains a staple in card magic due to its simplicity, visual appeal, and adaptability to different skill levels and performance styles.