Peanut Butter & Cheese by Josh Burch

Effect

The trick Peanut Butter & Cheese is a visual card routine where six cards—three with blue backs and three with red backs—mix together and then cleanly separate, mimicking the classic "oil and water" effect. The cards appear to defy logic as they alternate colors, then suddenly regroup by color with a simple flick or shake. The presentation is playful, often using the food-themed contrast of peanut butter and cheese to enhance the effect.

Full Details

Created by Josh Burch, Peanut Butter & Cheese is a modern take on the oil-and-water plot. The trick uses gaffed cards to achieve a strong visual separation without complex sleight-of-hand. Performers can emphasize fairness by showing the backs clearly before and after the mixing phase. The routine is fast-paced, making it suitable for both close-up and casual performances.

Who Should Consider the Trick

This trick is ideal for magicians who want a visually striking routine with minimal sleight-of-hand. It works well for performers who enjoy playful presentations or themed magic. Beginners will appreciate its ease of execution, while experienced magicians can use it as a quick, impactful piece in their sets.

Information on How Difficult It Is to Perform

Peanut Butter & Cheese is described as easy to perform, requiring only basic card handling skills. The trick relies on clever gaffs rather than advanced techniques, making it accessible to most magicians. The hardest part is likely the timing and presentation to maximize the visual impact.

What Magicians Say

• AlakazamMagicUK included Peanut Butter & Cheese in a live stream, highlighting it as one of several new tricks worth watching.
• Penguin Magic called it "super visual" and "easy to perform," noting its playful take on the oil-and-water plot.
• Magic-TV (Craig Petty) praised the trick's fairness and visual appeal, performing it multiple times to showcase its clean separation.
• Magic-TV (Craig and Ryland) rated it 95/100, calling it a clever and visually strong routine.

The consensus is that Peanut Butter & Cheese is a fun, fast, and visually engaging trick suitable for a wide range of performers.