The Burning by Andy Nyman

Effect

The Burning by Andy Nyman is a visually striking and deceptive trick that plays with the audience's perception of chance and skill. A spectator selects and marks a match from a bowl filled with hundreds of others. After mixing the matches, the performer—blindfolded or with eyes closed—plucks the exact marked match from the pile, seemingly against impossible odds. The effect is a powerful demonstration of intuition, misdirection, and theatrical timing, leaving the audience questioning how such a precise selection could be made.

Full Details

The Burning is a versatile trick that can be performed in close-up or stage settings. It involves a bowl filled with matches, a spectator’s marked match, and a series of deliberate actions that build suspense. The performer guides the spectator through a process of mixing and selecting, creating the illusion of randomness. The climax occurs when the performer, seemingly without any visual cues, retrieves the marked match from the bowl. The method relies on clever psychological forces and subtle handling rather than complex sleight of hand, making it accessible yet deeply deceptive.

Who Should Consider the Trick

The Burning is ideal for performers who enjoy interactive, audience-driven magic with strong storytelling potential. It suits mentalists, close-up magicians, and stage performers looking for a visually engaging routine that plays big. Those who appreciate Andy Nyman’s approach to magic—rooted in theatricality and psychological impact—will find this trick particularly rewarding.

Difficulty Level

The Burning is not technically demanding, making it suitable for magicians of varying skill levels. The challenge lies in the presentation—timing, audience management, and selling the impossibility of the feat. Performers must focus on pacing and emotional engagement to maximize the effect. As Matthew Pomeroy notes, "The beauty is in the simplicity and practicality... it’s about hooking the audience and making them care."

What Magicians Say

• Matthew Pomeroy describes The Burning as "delicious magic" and praises its deceptive simplicity. He highlights its versatility, suggesting it can be adapted for different performance styles, such as incorporating fire or other thematic elements.
• The trick’s strength lies in its believability—spectators often question whether it’s a genuine skill or pure magic. Pomeroy notes, "It feels real because you’re doing what you say you’re doing."
• Performers appreciate its potential for customization. Pomeroy mentions experimenting with presentations, such as adding a countdown or using audience participation to heighten tension.

The Burning is a standout trick for its blend of visual impact and psychological intrigue, making it a valuable addition to any magician’s repertoire.