Sleightful logoSleightful

The Impossible Prediction

The Impossible Prediction is a mind-blowing close-up card trick where the magician appears to predict a card chosen through a series of completely random actions by the spectator. The spectator shuffles the deck thoroughly, deals cards freely into piles, and splits them—all while the magician's prediction, made before any actions, matches the exact card determined by the spectator's choices. This trick combines elements of mentalism and card magic, creating a strong, self-working effect that requires no sleight of hand. Buyers should note that while the method is simple, the presentation and timing are crucial to maximize the trick's impact.

Key features

  • Self-working—no advanced skills required

  • Spectator does all the handling, making it seem impossible

  • Strong mentalism angle with a prediction reveal

  • Works with any borrowed deck

Pros

  • Instant, strong reactions from audiences

  • No setup needed—ready to perform immediately

  • Highly visual and interactive for spectators

Cons

  • Relies heavily on presentation for maximum effect

  • May require practice to perfect the timing and false recap

Effect

The Impossible Prediction is a card trick where the magician appears to predict a card chosen completely at random by the spectator. The spectator shuffles the deck, deals cards freely, and splits them into two piles. The magician reveals that two cards from these piles match a prediction made at the beginning, despite the spectator having full control over every step.

Full details

The trick begins with the spectator shuffling the deck thoroughly. The magician removes one card as a prediction, placing it face down in full view. The spectator then deals cards onto the table, stopping whenever they choose. They split this pile into two smaller piles. The magician explains that the top cards of these piles will determine the value and suit of the predicted card. When revealed, the prediction matches perfectly.

The method relies on a clever setup where the magician subtly controls two key cards during the initial shuffle. The spectator’s actions unknowingly bring these cards into position, making the trick appear completely fair.

Who should consider the trick

This trick is ideal for beginners and experienced magicians alike. It requires no advanced sleight of hand, making it accessible to those new to card magic. The strong audience interaction and apparent impossibility make it a great choice for performers who want a quick, impactful effect.

Information on how difficult it is to perform

The Impossible Prediction is classified as self-working, meaning it relies on method rather than skill. The hardest part is delivering the presentation convincingly. As Matt McGurk notes, the false recap—where the magician slightly misdirects the spectator about the sequence of events—is crucial for making the trick feel impossible. A little practice ensures smooth execution.

What magicians say

Matt McGurk describes The Impossible Prediction as "very very strong" and emphasizes its simplicity. He highlights the importance of the false recap, stating, "this is what turns it into a miracle." He also reassures performers that if the initial setup isn’t perfect, they can simply have the spectator shuffle again, adding to the entertainment value.

The trick’s strength lies in its fairness—the spectator does all the handling, making the outcome seem genuinely random. As McGurk puts it, "there is absolutely no way that I could have controlled this outcome." This makes it a reliable and baffling addition to any magician’s routine.

What people are saying about The Impossible Prediction

MattMcGurk says...

This is a very very strong trick... The Spectator can Shuffle these however they'd like, and then when you get the cards back, you're going to show the cards are well mixed. [...] The false recap is what turns it into a miracle.

Tutorial videos