Thy Will Be Done by Alexander Marsh

Effect

"Thy Will Be Done" by Alexander Marsh is a mentalism trick that creates the illusion of free will. A spectator interacts with three objects—a watch, a pen, and a coin—making choices that feel entirely their own. The magician then reveals a tarot card that mysteriously reflects the spectator’s decisions, including the exact time they set on the watch. The effect is strong, leaving the audience with a sense of eerie coincidence or supernatural insight.

Full details

The trick includes two tarot cards—one standard tarot size and one poker size—both featuring the same design. The cards depict a magician with symbolic objects (watch, pen, coin) that mirror the real-world items used in the performance. The spectator freely chooses which objects they keep, which the magician takes, and which remains on the table. The tarot card then reveals these choices, with an added kicker: the time shown on the card matches the time the spectator set on the watch.

A 37-minute tutorial video explains the method, covering all possible outcomes and performance tips. The trick requires an analog watch (not included), but any inexpensive watch with a date function will work.

Who should consider the trick

This trick is ideal for mentalists or magicians who want to incorporate tarot into their routines. It’s also great for performers who like interactive, free-choice effects. Fiddlin' Johnny notes that it’s beginner-friendly, while Steve Faulkner highlights its versatility for both casual and professional settings.

Information on how difficult it is to perform

The trick is easy to learn and perform. Fiddlin' Johnny states that you can start performing it within five minutes of watching the tutorial. There are no complex sleights or angle issues, making it accessible for all skill levels. The scripting is straightforward, though improvisation is possible for those who prefer a looser performance style.

What magicians say

• Fiddlin' Johnny calls it a "strong effect" with "great props" and appreciates the multiple outs covered in the tutorial. He notes that the trick feels fair to spectators, with no forced choices.
• Steve Faulkner praises its practicality, saying it fits in a wallet and works well in impromptu settings. He also highlights the strong audience reactions, calling it "really spooky."
• Alexander Marsh (creator) demonstrates how the trick can be integrated into other routines, such as coin bends or witch hand tricks, making it a versatile addition to a performer’s toolkit.

Overall, "Thy Will Be Done" is a well-received trick that combines simplicity with a powerful effect, making it a solid choice for mentalism and magic performers.