Witchfinder by Dave Forest

Effect

Witchfinder is a story-driven packet trick that blends a traditional card selection with a chilling Salem witch trial narrative. The routine begins with a freely chosen card, signed and lost in the deck. The performer then introduces four cards depicting moonlit woods on one side and beautiful maidens on the other. As the story unfolds, one maiden transforms into a burning witch, while the others reveal themselves as witches. The climax reveals the spectator's signed card at a predicted position in the deck.

Full Details

Witchfinder combines sleight of hand with storytelling to create an immersive experience. The trick uses an Elmsley count, cross-cut force, and double undercut to control the selected card. The packet cards are printed on durable card stock with detailed artwork that enhances the eerie atmosphere. One card is slightly gimmicked, but replacements are easy to source. The routine is flexible—it can stand alone or integrate into a broader card set.

Who Should Consider the Trick

Witchfinder suits magicians who enjoy narrative-driven magic. It works well for Halloween performances but is versatile enough for year-round use. Those comfortable with basic card controls and the Elmsley count will find it accessible. Performers looking to engage audiences beyond passive observation will appreciate the interactive elements.

Information on How Difficult It Is to Perform

The trick requires familiarity with the Elmsley count and basic card controls like the double undercut. Alex Kirk notes that Dave Forest’s tutorial on the Elmsley count is thorough, making it easier to learn. The storytelling aspect adds a layer of performance skill, but the mechanics are manageable for intermediate magicians.

What Magicians Say

Alex Kirk praises Witchfinder for its storytelling and audience engagement. He highlights the durable card stock and the trick’s ability to draw spectators into the routine. Kirk also commends the teaching of the Elmsley count, calling it "exceptionally good." He notes that while the trick isn’t entirely self-working, the sleights involved are straightforward for those with basic card skills.

Kirk emphasizes the trick’s versatility, stating it’s "ideal for Halloween but not so tied into Halloween that that's the only time you can perform it." The combination of visual transformations and a strong climax makes it a compelling addition to any magician’s repertoire.